6 Comments
User's avatar
Sofia Perrotta's avatar

Wonderful text Naomi! When I first got into the Brontë’s novels and read about the circumstances that they had to go through, from writing to publishing , I remember asking myself (and Charlotte) "why did she do that!?", since I'd have loved to see anything more of all of them. But as you brilliantly said, although it may hurt a little to know about what happened with the work and letters that one day existed, I do believe she was a woman, dealing with so much loss, who cared for her sisters and did what she thought it was the best for all of them. Thank you for sharing your consideration for Anne and the Brontë’s with us 🤎

Expand full comment
Scarlett's avatar

I really appreciate the nuance you approach this topic with. It’s so easy to make a snap judgment, especially in today’s age, when we are living in such different circumstances. I love all the sisters’ works so much, and feel a strong connection to them (even if in my mind lol). Anne was, in my opinion, perhaps the bravest of them, and most radical in many ways when you look at her work.

Have you read The Brontë Myth? I think you’d enjoy it. Though it focuses really only on Charlotte and Emily, it’s still worth a read imo.

Thanks again for this essay!

Expand full comment
Claire's avatar

I love this well thought defence. Charlotte is my favourite too. When I was alone and depressed abroad, Villette was my solace. Although sad, it made me feel understood and less alone.

Expand full comment
Naomi Elizabeth's avatar

I am the exact same. I relate to Lucy Snowe so much!

Expand full comment
Liz Is Writing's avatar

Fascinating!

Expand full comment
Melanie Sumner's avatar

This is a superb essay! I found it on a google search after watching a film about the Brontë sisters. I have never read Anne's work, but I look forward to doing so!

Expand full comment